Leica R Summicron 35 v1 vs v2, these two lenses are not just optical tools; they represent a chapter in the evolution of photographic excellence. The Leica R system, a bastion of rangefinder photography, saw the Summicron 35mm lens evolve over time, with the v1 and v2 versions marking significant milestones.
The v1, released in 1973, set a benchmark for sharpness and contrast, while the v2, introduced in 1989, refined its predecessor with a new design and a focus on modern image rendering. These lenses are more than just glass; they are instruments that capture moments in time, and their differences tell a story of photographic progress.
Understanding the distinctions between the v1 and v2 versions goes beyond mere technical specifications. It’s about appreciating how these lenses, born from different eras, influence the final image. From the subtle variations in sharpness and bokeh to the distinct character of their flare, the v1 and v2 versions offer distinct perspectives on the world, catering to different photographic styles and preferences.
The Leica R Summicron 35mm: A Legacy of Excellence
The Leica R Summicron 35mm lens stands as a testament to the enduring legacy of Leica’s craftsmanship and innovation in the world of photography. Introduced in 1958, this lens quickly became a staple for professionals and enthusiasts alike, renowned for its exceptional image quality and compact design.
Its enduring popularity is a testament to its enduring relevance in the ever-evolving landscape of photography.The lens’s evolution reflects the changing demands of photographers and the advancements in lens technology. From its initial release, the Summicron 35mm has undergone several revisions, each addressing specific needs and incorporating new technological advancements.
The v1 and v2 versions, though visually similar, embody distinct characteristics that set them apart in terms of performance and design.
The Leica R Summicron 35mm v1 and v2: Distinctive Features
The Leica R Summicron 35mm v1, released in 1958, is a classic example of early lens design. It features a six-element, five-group construction, employing a symmetrical optical formula. The lens is characterized by its relatively compact size, making it an ideal choice for street photography and documentary work.The Leica R Summicron 35mm v2, released in 1979, represents a significant upgrade over its predecessor.
This version incorporates a seven-element, six-group construction, featuring a redesigned optical formula. The v2 boasts improved image sharpness and contrast, particularly at wider apertures, while maintaining the compact design of the v1.
Key Differences
- Optical Formula:The v1 employs a six-element, five-group construction, while the v2 features a seven-element, six-group construction.
- Image Quality:The v2 generally exhibits improved image sharpness and contrast, particularly at wider apertures, compared to the v1.
- Minimum Focusing Distance:The v1 has a minimum focusing distance of 0.7 meters, while the v2 has a slightly closer minimum focusing distance of 0.6 meters.
- Filter Size:Both versions use a 39mm filter thread.
- Weight:The v1 weighs approximately 200 grams, while the v2 weighs slightly more at 220 grams.
Optical Performance: Leica R Summicron 35 V1 Vs V2
The Leica R Summicron 35mm f/2 lenses, both the v1 and v2 versions, are renowned for their exceptional optical performance. This section delves into the nuanced differences in their sharpness, contrast, color rendition, bokeh, flare, and distortion, highlighting how these variations impact photographic styles and subjects.
Sharpness and Contrast
Sharpness and contrast are crucial aspects of lens performance, influencing image clarity and detail. The Leica R Summicron 35mm v1, known for its vintage charm, exhibits a slightly softer rendering compared to the v2. The v1’s softer character is often attributed to its older design, which includes fewer lens elements.
The v1’s softer rendering can be characterized as a pleasing “glow” or “dreamy” look, often sought after by photographers for portraiture or landscapes where a softer, more romantic aesthetic is desired.
In contrast, the v2 boasts superior sharpness and contrast, particularly in the center of the frame. This increased sharpness provides greater detail and clarity, making it ideal for subjects requiring precise rendering, such as architecture or photojournalism.
The v2’s sharper rendering offers a more clinical and precise look, capturing details with greater accuracy and precision.
Color Rendition
Color rendition is the way a lens reproduces colors, impacting the overall mood and feel of an image. Both the v1 and v2 Summicron 35mm lenses are known for their accurate and natural color reproduction. However, subtle differences exist.
The v1 often exhibits a slightly warmer color rendition, with a subtle golden hue that can add warmth and nostalgia to images.
The v2, on the other hand, tends to have a slightly cooler color rendition, producing a more neutral and balanced image. This cooler tone can be advantageous for subjects requiring precise color accuracy, such as landscapes or product photography.
Bokeh, Flare, and Distortion
Bokeh, flare, and distortion are rendering characteristics that can significantly influence the overall look and feel of an image.
Bokeh
Bokeh, the out-of-focus areas in an image, is a subjective aspect of lens performance. Both the v1 and v2 Summicron 35mm lenses produce pleasing bokeh, but their rendering differs.
The v1’s bokeh is often described as “swirly” or “dreamy,” with a more pronounced swirl effect in out-of-focus areas. This can be an appealing characteristic for photographers seeking a more romantic or artistic look.
The v2, with its newer design, tends to produce a smoother and more consistent bokeh. This smoother bokeh can be advantageous for subjects requiring a more refined and controlled out-of-focus rendering.
Flare
Flare, the ghosting or halos that can appear in images when strong light sources are present, is a common phenomenon in lens design.
Both the v1 and v2 Summicron 35mm lenses are known for their excellent flare resistance. However, the v2’s multi-coating technology provides slightly better flare control, producing less ghosting and halos in challenging lighting conditions.
Distortion
Distortion, the warping of straight lines in an image, is another aspect of lens performance.
Both the v1 and v2 Summicron 35mm lenses exhibit minimal distortion, making them suitable for architectural or landscape photography where straight lines are crucial. The v2, however, exhibits slightly less distortion, offering even greater accuracy in rendering straight lines.
Features and Functionality
The Leica R Summicron 35mm lenses, both the v1 and v2 versions, are renowned for their exceptional optical performance, but they also offer distinct features and functionalities that contribute to their unique character and practical use. These differences, primarily in their focusing mechanisms and minimum focusing distances, impact their versatility and suitability for various photographic scenarios.
Focusing Mechanisms
The focusing mechanisms of the Leica R Summicron 35mm v1 and v2 versions differ significantly, reflecting the evolution of lens design and technological advancements.
- The v1 version utilizes a helical focusing mechanism, a traditional design where the lens elements are moved along a threaded shaft to achieve focus. This mechanism, while robust and reliable, requires a more deliberate and precise turning of the focusing ring to achieve sharp focus.
- The v2 version, however, features a floating element focusing system. This innovative design allows for improved sharpness across the entire focusing range by shifting a specific lens element to optimize image quality at different distances. The v2 version also incorporates a more refined focusing ring with a smoother feel and a more responsive action.
These differences in focusing mechanisms directly impact the user experience. The v1 version, with its helical focusing, provides a more tactile and controlled focusing experience, but it requires more practice and precision to achieve optimal sharpness. The v2 version, with its floating element system, offers a smoother and more responsive focusing experience, making it easier to achieve sharp focus, especially at close distances.
Minimum Focusing Distance and Maximum Aperture
The minimum focusing distance and maximum aperture are crucial factors that influence the versatility and practical use of a lens.
- The v1 version has a minimum focusing distance of 0.7 meters (2.3 feet), while the v2 version offers a closer minimum focusing distance of 0.5 meters (1.6 feet).
- Both versions feature a maximum aperture of f/2, which allows for shallow depth of field and excellent low-light performance.
The closer minimum focusing distance of the v2 version provides greater versatility for close-up photography, allowing photographers to capture more intimate and detailed shots. The wider maximum aperture of both versions enables photographers to create stunning bokeh effects and capture images in low-light conditions.
Usage and Applications
The Leica R Summicron 35mm lenses, both the v1 and v2, have earned a reputation for versatility, making them suitable for a wide range of photographic genres. Their exceptional optical performance and compact size have attracted photographers across various disciplines, from street photography to portraiture and landscapes.
This section explores the strengths and weaknesses of each version in specific shooting scenarios and provides examples of photographers who have utilized them to achieve remarkable results.
Street Photography
The Leica R Summicron 35mm, with its discreet size and fast aperture, is an ideal choice for street photography. Its ability to capture candid moments in a natural and unobtrusive way has made it a favorite among street photographers. The v1 version, known for its slightly softer rendering, can create a more intimate and evocative feel in street photos, while the v2’s sharper rendering provides more detail and clarity.
The Leica R Summicron 35mm f/2 V1 and V2 are both celebrated lenses, known for their sharpness and character. While the V2 boasts improved coatings and a slightly faster aperture, the V1 holds a unique vintage charm. When pairing these lenses with a camera like the Sony a7S II, you can unlock the full potential of its dynamic range by shooting in ProRes RAW, as described in this detailed article about a7sii prores raw dynamic range.
This allows you to capture and manipulate the subtle nuances of light and shadow, a perfect match for the nuanced rendering of the Summicron lenses. Whether you choose the V1 or V2, the combination promises a beautiful and cinematic result.
- Leica R Summicron 35mm v1:The slightly softer rendering of the v1 can create a more romantic and timeless feel, ideal for capturing the nuances of street life and human interaction. Its subtle bokeh can add depth and a sense of intimacy to street photographs, drawing the viewer’s attention to the subject.
The Leica R Summicron 35mm f/2 is a legendary lens, and the debate between the first and second versions is a classic among photographers. While the v2 boasts improved sharpness and contrast, the v1 is known for its softer rendering and unique character.
To get a sense of the potential for both lenses, it’s helpful to see how they perform in different lighting conditions. For example, checking out canon t6 photo samples can offer insights into how these cameras capture detail and color.
Ultimately, the choice between the Leica R Summicron 35 v1 and v2 comes down to personal preference and the specific photographic style you want to achieve.
- Leica R Summicron 35mm v2:The sharper rendering of the v2 provides more detail and clarity, making it suitable for capturing fast-paced street scenes and documenting urban life. Its ability to render fine details can be beneficial for photographers who prefer a more documentary approach to street photography.
Portraiture
The Leica R Summicron 35mm is a versatile lens for portraiture, offering a natural perspective and pleasing bokeh. Its ability to render skin tones beautifully and create a flattering depth of field makes it a popular choice for both formal and informal portraits.
- Leica R Summicron 35mm v1:The v1’s slightly softer rendering can create a more flattering and forgiving look for portraits, especially when shooting with a wide aperture. This can help to minimize imperfections and create a more artistic and timeless feel.
- Leica R Summicron 35mm v2:The v2’s sharper rendering can be beneficial for photographers who prefer a more detailed and realistic approach to portraiture. Its ability to capture fine details can be advantageous for shooting portraits in studio settings or for showcasing the subject’s features in a more defined manner.
The Leica R Summicron 35mm f/2, a lens known for its sharpness and character, presents a fascinating choice between the V1 and V2 versions. While both offer excellent image quality, the V2 boasts improved contrast and a more modern design.
To fully capture the detail and sharpness of this lens, a sturdy tripod is essential, especially for low-light or long-exposure photography. A good tripod can help you achieve perfect focus and minimize camera shake, maximizing the potential of your Leica R Summicron 35mm, whether you choose the V1 or V2.
For recommendations on the best tripods for photography , check out this comprehensive guide.
Landscape Photography
The Leica R Summicron 35mm can be a valuable tool for landscape photography, offering a wide field of view that allows for capturing expansive scenes. Its sharp rendering and excellent contrast can help to create dramatic and impactful landscapes.
- Leica R Summicron 35mm v1:The v1’s slightly softer rendering can create a more atmospheric and evocative feel in landscapes, particularly when shooting with a wide aperture. This can help to emphasize the mood and atmosphere of the scene, creating a more romantic and impressionistic effect.
- Leica R Summicron 35mm v2:The v2’s sharper rendering can be beneficial for photographers who prefer a more detailed and realistic approach to landscape photography. Its ability to capture fine details can be advantageous for showcasing the texture and intricacies of the landscape.
Low-Light Photography
The Leica R Summicron 35mm, with its fast f/2 aperture, is well-suited for low-light photography. Its ability to gather light effectively allows for shooting in challenging lighting conditions without resorting to high ISO settings, minimizing noise and preserving image quality.
- Leica R Summicron 35mm v1:The v1’s slightly softer rendering can be beneficial in low-light conditions, as it can help to smooth out noise and create a more pleasing image. This can be particularly helpful when shooting at higher ISO settings.
- Leica R Summicron 35mm v2:The v2’s sharper rendering can be advantageous in low-light conditions, as it can help to preserve detail and clarity even at higher ISO settings. This can be beneficial for photographers who prioritize sharpness and detail in their low-light images.
The Leica R Summicron 35mm f/2, both versions 1 and 2, are known for their exceptional sharpness and character. Their rendering of detail, particularly in the bokeh, can be exquisite, making them ideal for capturing the delicate textures and intricate details of floral still life photography.
These lenses, with their ability to render subtle nuances of light and shadow, can truly capture the beauty of a bouquet, as seen in this guide on floral still life photography. While the Summicron 35mm v2 offers slightly improved contrast and sharpness, the v1 retains a slightly warmer tone, a quality that some photographers prefer for their floral still life work.
Macro Work
While not specifically designed for macro photography, the Leica R Summicron 35mm can be used for close-up work with the assistance of extension tubes. This allows for capturing interesting details and textures in a creative way.
- Leica R Summicron 35mm v1:The v1’s slightly softer rendering can create a more artistic and painterly feel in macro images, emphasizing the textures and details of the subject.
- Leica R Summicron 35mm v2:The v2’s sharper rendering can provide more detail and clarity in macro images, allowing for capturing fine textures and intricate details.
Availability and Value
The Leica R Summicron 35mm lenses, both the v1 and v2 versions, are highly sought-after by photographers and collectors, making their availability and value an important consideration. Their legacy of exceptional optical performance, combined with their historical significance and limited production runs, has contributed to their desirability and high resale value.
Market Availability and Pricing
The availability of these lenses varies depending on the version, condition, and seller. Both versions can be found on online marketplaces like eBay, KEH, and used camera stores. The v1 version, being older and less common, is generally harder to find compared to the v2.
The price range for the v1 can vary significantly, from around $1,000 to $3,000 or more, depending on the condition and accessories. The v2, being more readily available, can be found for prices ranging from $700 to $1,500, again depending on condition.
Value Proposition
The Leica R Summicron 35mm lenses offer a compelling value proposition, particularly for photographers seeking exceptional optical performance, a compact design, and a classic look. The v1, known for its unique character and rendering, is often favored by those who appreciate the subtle vintage look it produces.
The v2, while not as widely sought-after as the v1, still offers excellent image quality and a more modern design.
Factors Influencing Price and Desirability
Several factors influence the price and desirability of these lenses in the used market:
- Condition:The condition of the lens is a major factor determining its price. Lenses in excellent condition, with minimal signs of wear and tear, command higher prices.
- Accessories:The inclusion of original accessories, such as the lens hood, lens cap, and original box, can significantly increase the value.
- Rarity:The v1, being a limited production lens, is generally more expensive than the v2.
- Demand:The demand for these lenses fluctuates based on market trends and the popularity of Leica R system cameras.
- Reputation:The Leica R Summicron 35mm lenses are highly regarded for their optical performance and build quality, which contributes to their high value.
“The Leica R Summicron 35mm lenses represent a pinnacle of optical engineering, offering exceptional image quality and a timeless design.”
Conclusion
The Leica R Summicron 35mm f/2 lenses, both versions, represent the pinnacle of optical engineering and craftsmanship. They have been cherished by photographers for decades for their exceptional image quality, compact size, and classic design. While both versions share a common heritage and many similarities, their differences offer distinct advantages depending on the photographer’s needs and preferences.
Choosing the Right Version, Leica r summicron 35 v1 vs v2
Understanding the subtle differences between the Leica R Summicron 35mm v1 and v2 is crucial for making an informed decision. The v1, with its classic design and vintage charm, appeals to photographers who appreciate the character and imperfections that come with older lenses.
It’s ideal for those seeking a unique look and a more tactile shooting experience. The v2, on the other hand, offers modern improvements like enhanced sharpness, better contrast, and improved close-focusing capabilities. It’s a perfect choice for photographers who prioritize technical perfection and versatility in their work.
- Leica R Summicron 35mm v1: This lens is renowned for its beautiful rendering of light and its ability to create a subtle, dreamy aesthetic. It is particularly well-suited for portraiture, street photography, and landscape photography where a classic, timeless look is desired. The v1 also offers a more intimate and engaging shooting experience due to its mechanical focusing and aperture ring.
- Leica R Summicron 35mm v2: The v2 version is a modern classic, delivering exceptional sharpness, clarity, and contrast across the entire image frame. It is an excellent choice for photographers who demand technical perfection in their images, especially those working in demanding situations like photojournalism, architecture, or product photography.
The v2 also boasts improved close-focusing capabilities, making it more versatile for close-up work.
Enduring Legacy
The Leica R Summicron 35mm lenses, both versions, have left an indelible mark on the world of photography. They have been used by countless photographers to capture iconic images and have played a pivotal role in shaping the visual landscape of our time.
Their reputation for exceptional quality, timeless design, and enduring value has cemented their status as legendary lenses that will continue to inspire photographers for generations to come.
Ultimate Conclusion
The Leica R Summicron 35mm v1 and v2 lenses stand as testaments to the enduring legacy of Leica’s commitment to optical excellence. While both versions offer exceptional image quality, the v1 represents a classic approach, emphasizing sharpness and detail, while the v2 embodies a more contemporary aesthetic, with a touch of softness and a nuanced rendering of light.
Ultimately, the choice between these two lenses depends on the individual photographer’s creative vision and shooting style. Whether you seek the vintage character of the v1 or the refined performance of the v2, both lenses offer a unique and captivating window into the world of photography.