Tamron 100 400 vs sigma 100 400 – Tamron 100-400 vs Sigma 100-400: Two titans of the telephoto lens world, these lenses are popular choices for wildlife and sports photographers. Both offer impressive reach, but which one reigns supreme? Let’s delve into the details to find out.
Tamron and Sigma are both well-respected lens manufacturers known for producing high-quality optics. The Tamron 100-400mm and Sigma 100-400mm lenses are both popular choices for photographers who need a versatile telephoto lens for capturing wildlife, sports, and other fast-paced action.
Both lenses offer a similar focal length range, but there are some key differences in their performance, features, and price that might make one a better choice for you than the other.
Image Quality
Both the Tamron 100-400mm f/5-6.3 Di VC USD G2 and the Sigma 100-400mm f/5-6.3 DG OS Contemporary lenses are known for their excellent image quality, offering sharp and detailed images even at their longest focal lengths. However, there are some subtle differences in their performance that may be important to consider depending on your specific needs and shooting style.
Sharpness and Clarity
The sharpness and clarity of images produced by both lenses are generally excellent, especially when stopped down to f/8 or f/11. At wider apertures, the Tamron lens tends to exhibit slightly softer images, particularly at the longer focal lengths. This is due to the lens’s design, which prioritizes a smaller and lighter form factor over absolute sharpness at wide apertures.
The Sigma lens, on the other hand, delivers sharper images at wider apertures, making it a better choice for photographers who frequently shoot at f/5.6 or f/6.3.
The Tamron lens is a good choice for photographers who prioritize a compact and lightweight lens, while the Sigma lens is better suited for photographers who need the best possible sharpness at wider apertures.
Chromatic Aberration
Chromatic aberration, the colorful fringing that can occur around high-contrast edges, is well-controlled in both lenses. However, the Tamron lens exhibits slightly more noticeable chromatic aberration at the longer focal lengths and wider apertures. This is a common characteristic of telephoto lenses, but the Tamron lens seems to struggle slightly more in this regard.
The Sigma lens, on the other hand, generally exhibits less chromatic aberration, particularly at the longer focal lengths. This makes it a better choice for photographers who shoot subjects with high-contrast edges, such as landscapes and wildlife.
Distortion
Both lenses exhibit minimal distortion, which is generally well-corrected by most image editing software. The Tamron lens tends to exhibit slightly more barrel distortion at the wide end of the zoom range, while the Sigma lens shows slightly more pincushion distortion at the telephoto end.
However, these distortions are minor and should not be a major concern for most photographers.
Vignetting
Vignetting, the darkening of the image corners, is also well-controlled in both lenses. The Tamron lens exhibits slightly more vignetting at wider apertures, particularly at the longer focal lengths. This is again a common characteristic of telephoto lenses, but the Tamron lens seems to struggle slightly more in this regard.
The Sigma lens, on the other hand, generally exhibits less vignetting, particularly at the longer focal lengths. This makes it a better choice for photographers who frequently shoot at wider apertures or need to maximize the amount of light captured in the corners of their images.
Size and Weight: Tamron 100 400 Vs Sigma 100 400
The size and weight of a lens significantly influence its portability, handling, and overall usability, especially for photographers who frequently travel or shoot wildlife. Let’s delve into the dimensions and weight of the Tamron 100-400mm f/5.6-6.3 Di VC USD and Sigma 100-400mm f/5-6.3 DG OS Contemporary lenses to understand their impact on the shooting experience.
Dimensions and Weight
The Tamron 100-400mm f/5.6-6.3 Di VC USD lens measures approximately 7.7 inches (196 mm) in length and has a maximum diameter of 3.4 inches (86 mm). It weighs 2.2 pounds (1 kg), making it a relatively compact and lightweight option.
The Sigma 100-400mm f/5-6.3 DG OS Contemporary lens, on the other hand, is slightly longer at 8.1 inches (206 mm) and slightly heavier at 2.5 pounds (1.1 kg). The Tamron lens’s smaller size and lighter weight make it more portable and easier to carry around.
Choosing between the Tamron 100-400mm and the Sigma 100-400mm for action shots comes down to personal preference and specific needs. Both lenses boast impressive reach, but understanding the nuances of capturing fast-paced moments is crucial. To get the best results, it’s essential to consider the overall camera system, including factors like autofocus speed and continuous shooting capabilities, as described in this comprehensive guide on choosing a good camera for action shots.
Ultimately, the ideal lens will depend on the specific action you’re photographing, whether it’s wildlife, sports, or even street photography.
Its compact design makes it suitable for travel photography and wildlife shooting, especially when hiking or trekking. The Sigma lens, while slightly larger and heavier, remains manageable and offers a more robust feel.
Impact on Portability and Handling
The weight and size of a lens directly impact its portability and handling. A heavier lens can be tiring to carry for extended periods, especially when shooting handheld. The Tamron lens’s lighter weight and compact size offer a significant advantage in this regard.
The Tamron 100-400mm and Sigma 100-400mm lenses are both popular choices for wildlife and sports photography, offering excellent reach and image quality. But when considering the cost of these lenses, it’s worth factoring in the overall expense of your photo shoot.
The average cost for family photos, which can be found here , can vary significantly depending on factors like location, photographer experience, and desired package. Ultimately, choosing between the Tamron and Sigma lens depends on your budget and specific photographic needs.
For photographers who prioritize portability, the Tamron lens’s smaller footprint makes it an attractive choice. However, the Sigma lens’s slightly larger size and weight might be preferred by photographers who value a more substantial feel in their hands, especially when shooting in challenging conditions.
Ease of Use and Balance
The balance of a lens on a camera body plays a crucial role in its ease of use and handling. A well-balanced lens feels more comfortable to hold and shoot with, reducing hand fatigue and improving stability. The Tamron lens, due to its lighter weight, tends to balance better on smaller camera bodies.
This makes it a suitable choice for photographers who use mirrorless cameras or entry-level DSLRs. The Sigma lens, with its slightly heavier weight, might require a larger camera body to achieve optimal balance, especially when using longer focal lengths. However, both lenses offer good balance on a variety of camera bodies.
The key is to find the right combination that feels comfortable and stable for your shooting style.
The Tamron 100-400mm and Sigma 100-400mm lenses are both popular choices for wildlife and sports photography, offering impressive reach and image quality. While both lenses excel in their own right, the choice often boils down to personal preference and specific shooting needs.
If you’re looking to expand your photography horizons beyond the realm of these telephoto lenses, consider venturing into the world of medium format photography. You might be surprised by the stunning results you can achieve with a digital camera 6×6 between $150 and $350 , which offers a unique perspective and exceptional image detail.
Ultimately, the best lens for you depends on your budget, shooting style, and desired results.
Features and Functionality
Both the Tamron 100-400mm f/5-6.3 Di VC USD G2 and the Sigma 100-400mm f/5-6.3 DG OS Contemporary lenses offer a range of features and functionalities designed to enhance their performance and usability. These features include image stabilization, autofocus modes, and lens hoods, among others.
Image Stabilization
Image stabilization is crucial for capturing sharp images, especially when shooting at longer focal lengths. Both lenses offer effective image stabilization systems.The Tamron 100-400mm G2 lens features Tamron’s proprietary Vibration Compensation (VC)system, which is known for its effectiveness in reducing camera shake.
This system provides up to 4 stops of compensation, according to Tamron.The Sigma 100-400mm Contemporary lens incorporates Sigma’s Optical Stabilization (OS)system. This system offers up to 4 stops of compensation, similar to the Tamron VC system. The effectiveness of both systems has been praised by photographers.
They have proven to be reliable in various shooting conditions, including low-light situations and when shooting handheld.
Autofocus Modes
Both lenses offer a variety of autofocus modes to cater to different shooting styles and situations.
Choosing between the Tamron 100-400mm and Sigma 100-400mm lenses often comes down to personal preference and specific shooting needs. Both offer impressive reach for wildlife and sports photography, but for those seeking a more traditional darkroom experience, digital negative inkjet film for contact printing provides a unique workflow.
This technology allows photographers to create physical negatives from digital files, enabling the creation of prints using traditional darkroom techniques. Ultimately, the choice between these lenses and the workflow for printing depends on the photographer’s individual style and desired outcome.
- Tamron 100-400mm G2: The Tamron lens features a USD (Ultrasonic Silent Drive)autofocus motor, known for its speed and accuracy. It offers various autofocus modes, including single-shot autofocus (AF-S), continuous autofocus (AF-C), and manual focus override. The lens also incorporates a full-time manual focusfeature, allowing for precise manual adjustments even when the autofocus is engaged.
- Sigma 100-400mm Contemporary: The Sigma lens features a stepping motorfor autofocus. It offers similar autofocus modes as the Tamron lens, including single-shot, continuous, and manual focus override. The lens also includes a customizable autofocus limiter switch, allowing photographers to restrict the autofocus range for faster focusing in specific situations.
Lens Hoods
Both lenses include detachable petal-shaped lens hoodsas standard accessories. These hoods effectively block stray light and reduce lens flare, contributing to improved image quality.
Optional Accessories
Both lenses offer a range of optional accessories to further enhance their functionality and usability.
- Tamron 100-400mm G2: Tamron offers a dedicated lens footfor mounting the lens on a tripod, enhancing stability and ease of use. They also offer a protective filterto minimize dust and scratches on the front element.
- Sigma 100-400mm Contemporary: Sigma offers a lens footfor tripod mounting, similar to Tamron. They also offer a protective filterand a dedicated lens casefor storage and transportation.
Usability and Practicality
Both lenses are designed with usability and practicality in mind. They offer a comfortable grip, ergonomic controls, and features that streamline the shooting process. The Tamron 100-400mm G2 lens features a zoom lock switch, preventing the lens from extending accidentally. It also includes a focus mode switchfor easy selection between autofocus and manual focus.The Sigma 100-400mm Contemporary lens features a zoom ring with a textured rubber gripfor improved control and comfort.
It also includes a customizable autofocus limiter switch, allowing photographers to tailor the autofocus range to their needs. Both lenses are relatively lightweight and compact, making them easier to carry and use in various shooting situations.
Price and Value
The Tamron and Sigma 100-400mm lenses are both excellent options for wildlife and sports photographers, but they come at different price points. Understanding their value proposition requires considering their performance, features, and pricing.
The Tamron 100-400mm and Sigma 100-400mm lenses are popular choices for wildlife and sports photography, each offering distinct strengths and weaknesses. Deciding between them often hinges on your camera system, as both lenses are available for both Sony and Canon.
If you’re like many photographers, you might be shooting with both Sony and Canon systems, making compatibility a key consideration. In this case, choosing the lens that works best across both systems is essential, as it can save you money and simplify your workflow.
Ultimately, the best lens for you will depend on your specific needs and shooting style.
Price Comparison
The retail prices of these lenses can fluctuate depending on the retailer and current promotions. However, here’s a general overview of their typical pricing:* Tamron 100-400mm G2:The retail price for this lens typically ranges from $1,300 to $1,500.
Sigma 100-400mm Contemporary
This lens usually retails for around $800 to $900.
Value Proposition
The Tamron 100-400mm G2 is a premium lens offering exceptional image quality, fast autofocus, and advanced features like weather sealing. Its higher price reflects these benefits. The Sigma 100-400mm Contemporary, on the other hand, is a more budget-friendly option, offering good image quality and performance at a lower price point.
Discounts and Promotions
Both lenses often experience price fluctuations and promotions. * Tamron:Look out for sales events like Black Friday, Cyber Monday, or seasonal discounts. Additionally, Tamron often offers rebates or bundle deals with other products.
Sigma
Sigma also participates in seasonal sales and promotional periods. Additionally, retailers like B&H Photo or Adorama frequently offer discounts on Sigma products.
It’s important to shop around and compare prices from different retailers to find the best deal.
Conclusion
The Tamron 100-400mm and Sigma 100-400mm lenses both offer exceptional performance for wildlife and sports photography. They deliver sharp images, excellent reach, and impressive autofocus speed. However, each lens has its strengths and weaknesses, making one a better choice depending on the user’s priorities.
Strengths and Weaknesses
The Tamron 100-400mm lens excels in its lightweight and compact design, making it more portable for photographers who frequently travel. It also offers a slightly wider aperture range, providing better low-light performance and shallower depth of field. However, the Tamron lens might lack the same level of sharpness and detail compared to the Sigma lens at the longer end of the zoom range.The Sigma 100-400mm lens boasts superior image quality, especially at the longer focal lengths.
It produces sharper images with better detail and contrast, making it ideal for capturing fine textures and intricate details in wildlife photography. While it offers slightly slower autofocus speeds, it compensates with exceptional image stabilization, ensuring sharper images even in challenging lighting conditions.
Target Audience, Tamron 100 400 vs sigma 100 400
The Tamron 100-400mm lens is an excellent choice for photographers who prioritize portability and value a lighter and more compact design. Its wider aperture and affordability make it an attractive option for wildlife and sports photographers who need to capture images in various lighting conditions.The Sigma 100-400mm lens is better suited for photographers who prioritize image quality and demand the highest level of detail and sharpness.
Its exceptional image stabilization makes it ideal for capturing wildlife in challenging lighting conditions or when shooting from a moving vehicle.
Recommendation
If you prioritize portability and a wider aperture, the Tamron 100-400mm lens is an excellent choice. Its lightweight design and affordable price make it an attractive option for photographers who frequently travel or need a versatile lens for various shooting scenarios.However, if image quality is your top priority, and you need the sharpest possible images with exceptional detail, the Sigma 100-400mm lens is the better option.
Its superior sharpness, contrast, and image stabilization make it ideal for wildlife photography, especially when shooting in challenging lighting conditions.
Last Point
The Tamron 100-400mm and Sigma 100-400mm lenses are both excellent choices for wildlife and sports photography. The Tamron lens offers slightly better image quality and autofocus performance, while the Sigma lens is more compact and affordable. Ultimately, the best lens for you will depend on your specific needs and budget.